| dc.contributor.author |
Dutton, Zachary |
|
| dc.date.accessioned |
2010-09-30T16:36:08Z |
|
| dc.date.available |
2010-09-30T16:36:08Z |
|
| dc.date.issued |
2010 |
|
| dc.identifier.uri |
http://hdl.handle.net/10066/5625 |
|
| dc.description.abstract |
I assess ritual theory and its relevance and workability in explaining postmodern Western societies, and I thereby arrive at a functional
definition for ritual. I center this functional definition within cultural theories in sociology, arguing that the crux of human action remains
squarely within ritualistic meaning making processes that reinforce values and (when needed) redress deviance. Punishment, therefore, is a kind of ritual. Punishment is a name for ritual when it redresses deviance. Restorative justice is another name for the same kind of ritual. I further structurally distinguish between punishment and restorative justice, arguing
that they are functionally equivalent. I achieve this argument by asserting that all ritual activity in postmodern Western societies is procedural: ritualistic and oriented to rational egalitarian values. Though restorative
justice is different in form than punishment, it takes the same function as punishment in Western societies in so far as all restorative justice
processes retain some "sanctioning" component. No restorative justice process is successful in redressing deviance in postmodern Western societies without at least the threat of negative sanctions, which would rest in the background. |
en |
| dc.description.provenance |
Submitted by Haverford Student (library@haverford.edu) on 2010-09-20T00:20:45Z
No. of bitstreams: 2
2010DuttonZ_release.pdf: 26577 bytes, checksum: 1dc024fe2d1aa4568da47731fc5926f8 (MD5)
2010DuttonZ_thesis.pdf: 390433 bytes, checksum: b91a87ace520955dfd4b7cd43ca3c634 (MD5) |
en |
| dc.description.provenance |
Made available in DSpace on 2010-09-30T16:36:08Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 2
2010DuttonZ_release.pdf: 26577 bytes, checksum: 1dc024fe2d1aa4568da47731fc5926f8 (MD5)
2010DuttonZ_thesis.pdf: 390433 bytes, checksum: b91a87ace520955dfd4b7cd43ca3c634 (MD5) |
en |
| dc.description.sponsorship |
Haverford College. Dept. of Sociology |
|
| dc.language.iso |
en_US |
en |
| dc.rights.uri |
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/us/ |
|
| dc.subject.lcsh |
Restorative justice |
|
| dc.subject.lcsh |
Restorative justice -- Sociological aspects |
|
| dc.subject.lcsh |
Criminal justice, Administration of |
|
| dc.subject.lcsh |
Ritual |
|
| dc.title |
Restorative Justice Doesn’t Work? In an effort to re-conceptualize punishment and to reevaluate restorative justice from the perspective of culture and ritual |
en |
| dc.type |
Thesis (B.A.) |
en |