Aeneas in the New World: Reshaping the Interpretive Motif in Barlow's Columbiad

TriCollege Digital Repository

Title: Aeneas in the New World: Reshaping the Interpretive Motif in Barlow's Columbiad
Author: Carroll, Thomas Eliot
Advisor: Mulligan, Bret
Department: Haverford College. Dept. of Classics
Type: Thesis (B.A.)
Issue Date: 2010
Abstract: Barlow's Columbiad evokes Virgil's Aeneid by using the motifs of revelation and interpretation to explore the role of the past in informing the present. Virgil creates an opposition between Aeneas, who receives prophecies and signs but is prevented from interpreting them by his shock and fear, and his father Anchises, who interprets the prophecies and guides the Trojans. Aeneas learns to use his father's interpretive ritual but must utilize this technique to craft forward-looking interpretations and lead his people into the unknown, in order to fulfill his destiny. This combination of traditional ritual with a progressive outlook reflects symbolically the new political circumstances of Virgil's Rome. In the Columbiad, Columbus views scenes from early American history, and presents Hesper with the problems and criticisms he sees in the nation's development, relying on Hesper to explain them. Through their intermittent dialogue, the two advocate cyclical and linear models of historical development, respectively. Hesper's interpretation of mankind's progressive improvement prevails, reflecting Barlow's vision of post-revolutionary America as distinct from and improving upon its Old World predecessors. The two epics' common motif reveals the complexity of Columbus' character and reinforces Barlow's democratic message.
Subject: Barlow, Joel, 1754-1812 -- Criticism and interpretation
Subject: Virgil. Aeneis
Subject: Columbus, Christopher
Subject: Barlow, Joel, 1754-1812. Columbiad
Subject: Virgil -- Criticism and interpretation
Subject: America -- Discovery and exploration
Terms of Use:
Permanent URL:

Files in this item

Files Description Size Format
2010CarrollT.pdf Thesis 1.544Mb PDF
Haverford_departmental_permission.pdf **Archive Staff Only** 30.60Kb PDF
2010CarrollT_release_for_ILL.pdf **Archive Staff Only** 19.71Kb PDF


Carroll, Thomas Eliot. "Aeneas in the New World: Reshaping the Interpretive Motif in Barlow's Columbiad". 2010. Available electronically from

This item appears in the following Collection(s) Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as


Advanced Search


My Account